Independent property claims expertise

An opinion that follows the evidence.

Claims consulting, appraisal, Xactimate estimating, and expert work for carriers and policyholder counsel. Residential and commercial property, across Louisiana and the Mississippi Gulf Coast.

[email protected] · New Orleans metro area

  • Residential & commercial
  • Appraisal
  • Xactimate estimating
  • Expert reports & testimony
  • Louisiana & Mississippi Gulf Coast
Services

What we do

Every service covers residential and commercial property. Whoever retains us gets the same thing: a thorough, documented opinion that holds up.

Consulting

Independent claims consulting

Attorneys retain Dion to re-establish the claim from the ground up:

  • Review of all claim documents
  • On-site inspection and photo documentation
  • A written scope and Xactimate estimate
  • An expert report ready for deposition, when needed

For counsel

Expert work for attorneys

For policyholder counsel, with the same method Dion uses for carriers.

  • Claim file and estimate review
  • Written expert reports
  • Deposition and expert testimony

Dispute resolution

Appraisal

Serving as appraiser when the parties disagree on the amount of loss, with a well-supported, line-by-line position:

  • Policyholder-side appraisal, retained through counsel or by contractors
  • Carrier-side appraisal

Estimating

Xactimate estimating

Detailed, certified Xactimate estimates and scope documentation, plus follow-up re-inspections when the job calls for them.

Review

Estimate review & reconciliation

Independent, line-by-line review of competing estimates to show where they differ and why.

On site

Inspections & on-site assessments

Property inspections, damage documentation, and photo records, coordinated around your deadlines.

Train your team

Claims process training

Practical training for in-house teams on the claims process, documentation, and Xactimate.

Administration

Claims administration support

Help managing the claims process from start to finish, from a single claim to a larger book of files.

Scope: appraisal addresses the amount of loss, not coverage. We don't decide coverage questions.

Who we work with

Trusted by carriers and counsel

Carriers retain Dion as their appraiser; policyholder counsel and contractors retain him for consulting, appraisal, and expert work. The method is the same either way. Independence isn't a slogan here; it's what makes the work useful.

Attorneys

Policyholder counsel who need an estimate reviewed, an expert report written, or deposition testimony from someone who has handled claims for more than two decades.

Carriers, claims professionals & appraisal firms

Insurers, adjusting firms, appraisal firms, and claims teams who need an appraiser, an independent estimate, or training for their people.

Contractors

Residential and commercial contractors can retain Dion directly as their appraiser, or for a scope and Xactimate estimate that documents the loss correctly.

Track record

Results that hold up

A quarter century of claims work, thousands of files, and opinions that have been tested in appraisal, in deposition, and in federal court.

  • 25+years handling property claims, since 2001
  • 14,000+claims worked, residential and commercial
  • 6expert depositions since 2024
  • 2federal-court expert designations
  • $3.5Mlargest appraisal award: a condominium complex, 2022
  • 13+law firms worked with since 2022

Neutral by design

Carriers retain Dion as their appraiser. Policyholder counsel retain him as their consultant, expert, and appraiser. He applies the same method either way: review the full record, inspect and document the property, and build a line-by-line Xactimate estimate. The number is the one the evidence supports, whoever is paying for it.

Expert testimony

Dion prepares written expert reports and gives deposition testimony in first-party property disputes, in Louisiana and Florida state courts and in federal court. He has been designated as a testifying expert in two federal cases in the Northern District of Texas, and he has been cross-examined in deposition by national defense counsel. A list of matters is available to counsel on request.

“I have relied on Dion McKinley as a property claims consultant and expert in construction-defect and property-damage litigation for the better part of a decade. His site work and estimates are thorough, and he is candid about what the evidence will and will not support, which is exactly what a trial lawyer needs from an expert. Dion is my first call when a case turns on property damage or construction defects.”

Salvador Bivalacqua, Managing Partner, Bivalacqua, Gelé + Ellis

Figures are drawn from McKinley Claims Solutions' own files. Past results don't guarantee the outcome of any other matter.

Client reviews

What clients say

Rated 5.0 on Google — six reviews, all five stars.

“Our law firm has used Dion McKinley and his team on dozens of property damage claims and will continue to do so as long as he is in business. His reports are thorough and well supported and his team acts fast and professionally. Our clients also rave about how attentive and caring he is. For my clients and my personal home, I will be calling Dion first every time.”

Kevin Riche — Google review

“We had an excellent experience with Dion when resolving our home water damage claim which was being delayed by insurance. Dion was extremely knowledgeable, helpful and guiding throughout the process, and his services were just the thing we needed to see us through to a successful repair.”

Liam Sheehan-Dean — Google review

“Very knowledgeable, professional, and thorough. Excellent communication and attention to detail throughout the appraisal process. Highly recommend to anyone needing an experienced insurance loss appraiser.”

Joshua & Janette Guillot — Google review

How it works

How an engagement works

  1. Retain & conflict check

    Counsel, a carrier, or a contractor calls with the property, the parties, and any deadlines. We confirm there's no conflict.

  2. Review all claim documents

    Policy, correspondence, prior estimates, and reports, so the claim can be re-established from the record.

  3. Inspect & document

    On-site inspection with thorough photo documentation of the property and the loss.

  4. Scope, estimate & report

    A written scope and Xactimate estimate and, when needed, an expert report ready for deposition.

Dion McKinley, CGA
Dion McKinley, CGAOwner, McKinley Claims Solutions, LLC · New Orleans metro area
About

Meet Dion McKinley

Dion McKinley has handled property claims since 2001. He is an all-lines property adjuster whose background includes decades of catastrophe claims work on residential and commercial losses, from investigation and estimate through negotiation and settlement.

Through McKinley Claims Solutions, he is retained by carriers as their appraiser and by policyholder counsel and contractors. Whoever retains him gets the same thing: an independent opinion that follows the evidence. He is also open to umpire appointments.

Credentials

  • Louisiana Department of Insurance Registered Insurance Appraiser
  • Louisiana Adjuster License #445943
  • Also licensed as an adjuster in Texas, Mississippi, Alabama, Florida, South Carolina, North Carolina, Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Kentucky
  • Xactimate certified
  • NFIP flood certified

Save Dion's digital business card (opens in a new tab)

Service area

Louisiana and the Mississippi Gulf Coast

Based in the New Orleans metro area. In Texas, Mississippi, Alabama, Florida, South Carolina, North Carolina, Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Kentucky, where Dion is also licensed, we offer remote estimating, file review, training, and administrative support.

  • Louisiana
  • Mississippi Gulf Coast
  • Texas
  • Florida
  • Residential
  • Commercial

Looking for a Fortified roof evaluation? That work is handled separately through getfortifiednow.com (opens in a new tab).

Questions & answers

FAQ

Who retains you?

Carriers retain Dion as their appraiser, and policyholder counsel and contractors retain him for consulting, appraisal, and expert work. The method is the same either way, and the opinion follows the evidence no matter who calls.

Do you handle commercial claims?

Yes. Every service covers both residential and commercial property.

What's the difference between an appraiser and an umpire?

In the appraisal process, each side names an appraiser to set the amount of loss. If the two appraisers can't agree, a neutral umpire, chosen by the appraisers or appointed by a court, decides the items they disagree on.

Do you decide coverage?

No. Appraisal addresses the amount of loss, not coverage. Coverage questions are for the parties, their counsel, and the courts.

Do you work outside Louisiana?

Yes. In Texas, Mississippi, Alabama, Florida, South Carolina, North Carolina, Arkansas, Oklahoma, and Kentucky, where Dion also holds adjuster licenses, we offer remote estimating, file review, training, and administrative support.

Can you give deposition testimony?

Yes. Expert reports and deposition testimony are a core part of the work for attorneys.

What should I have ready?

The property address, the type of loss and date, the parties involved, any estimates you have, and your deadlines. We'll ask for the rest once we confirm there's no conflict.

Contact

Start a conversation

For attorneys, carriers, appraisal firms, and contractors. Call, email, or send the form. Please don't send confidential case documents through the form; we'll arrange a secure way to share files once we've talked.

QR code to save Dion McKinley's contact (opens in a new tab)
Scan to save my contact.

We use your information only to respond to you. See the privacy note.

Counsel, carriers, and contractors: need an independent opinion on a claim?

Call 504-237-3560